The 2011 Great Shoujo Manga Gift Guide!

I’m going to tell you right off the bat that this gift guide is lacking.

Why? Because I can’t recommend one of the biggest shoujo titles of the year since I happen to have worked on it. But don’t worry because nearly every other gift guide has mentioned it. See if you can figure out what I’m talking about. 🙂

…Moving on!

For the Disney nostalgic:
Princess Knight by Osamu Tezuka

Reading the Osamu Tezuka classic made me feel a lot like I was watching Snow White,  so if you know someone with a taste for the Disney princesses, flaws and all.  I wouldn’t recommend the title for kids, unless you think you can explain away some of the old-fashioned ideas about gender inequality. However, it does present an interesting character in Princess Sapphire, who has both a female and a male heart, and doesn’t want to give either one up. In this way, Princess Knight was well ahead of it’s time in terms of non-cisgender identities. Either way, Princess Knight is a fun read that will delight anyone who regularly pops Cinderella into their DVD player.

For the historical fiction buff:
A Bride’s Story by Kaoru Mori

If you have a friend or relative who is into The Red Tent just as much as they’re into comics, they’ll probably enjoy A Bride’s Story, which follows the marriage and family life of an unusual couple in late 19th Century Central Asia. Karluk, the groom, is only 12 years old, but his wife, Amira, is 20. Before you think “Ew, that sounds gross,” let me tell you that the manga presents their relationship in a very natural way, without only a few allusions to sexuality in the first two volumes. (And I should mention the fact that marriage between young girls and older men was common back then and is often addressed in historical fiction.) In between scenes about their relationship, Kaoru Mori weaves in beautifully-rendered stories about the surrounding culture, with special attention paid to the artwork and handicraft of the region. If your giftee has read Habibi by Craig Thompson, chances are they’ll love A Bride’s Story too.

For the inner goth:
Grand Guignol Orchestra by Kaori Yuki

Kaori Yuki is the one of the goth grand masters of manga and Grand Guignol Orchestra is her most enjoyable romp into a twisted fantasy world since Cain Saga. Actually, it might be my favorite work by her yet. The story takes place in an alternative version of Europe that is plagued by zombie-like creatures called guignols (French for puppet.) The only way to eradicate guignols is to have the mysterious Royal Court Orchestra perform. Of course, the orchestra is really after the secret of the guignols’ creation and the members must put themselves in danger in order to find out. Any goth tired of the usual vampire or zombie tale will enjoy Grand Guignol Orchestra‘s unique plot.

For the mythology fiend:
Kamisama Kiss by Julietta Suzuki

If you happen to have a friend who is heavily into mythology and shoujo manga, Kamisama Kiss is a perfectly cute gift choice. Nanami is suddenly homeless after her irressponsible father disappears, luckily for her, a strange man suddenly gives her his home. Unfortunately for Nanami, his home is a Shinto shrine, and she is now the kami (or god) in charge yokai servants. One of them, Tomoe, a fox yokai, is extremely unhappy to have to serve such a weak kami. The result is a treasure trove of fun and exciting stories with a parade of supernatural characters from Japanese mythology.

For the hopeless romantic:
Kimi ni Todoke by Karuho Shiina

Kimi ni Todoke is one of those manga where you latch hard onto the protagonist and the supporting characters, and then get taken on a wild, emotional ride with them. This solid empathy for the characters is a great testament to Karuho Shiina’s storytelling abilities because Kimi ni Todoke would otherwise be like every other high school romance manga out there. Perhaps the difference lies in socially awkward Sawako’s struggle to fit in and make friends, and how much most manga readers can relate to her. But it’s really Sawako’s slow journey to love that makes this a great gift for someone who just loves a really cute couple.

For someone who likes a-typical shoujo:
Seiho Boys’ High School! by Kaneyoshi Izumi

What makes Seiho Boys’ High  School! so different from other manga is that it immediately places itself in a situation not only where there almost no girls, but where there are a plethora of horny teenage boys. Somehow the story manages to be a shoujo manga instead of Maxim in manga form by focusing on the eternal teenage boy’s quest: having a cute girlfriend. Therein lies the problem of trying to convince the only ladies available that the guys at the boys’ school are worthy and not just trying to get into their pants, which plays out with great comedic effect. Some guys already have girlfriends, but that doesn’t mean they don’t have their own girl problems to deal with. The change of perspective brings a refreshing look at the usual shoujo tropes.

For the new fan:
X by CLAMP


Got a new fan who’s all over Tsubasa: Reservoir Chronicle or xxxHOLiC, but doesn’t know their manga classics? X is the perfect book to stuff in their stocking, especially with it’s high-drama, supernatural story line. With this 3-in-1 reissue, you can easily get them into the story without breaking their piggy bank in the future or without spending too much of your own cash in case they don’t like it. Luckily, any previous exposure to CLAMP will soften the blow of those gigantic, pointy shoulders and you can show them what emo looked like in the anime & manga crowd before Death Note came along.

For the fan who’s hot for tsundere (men):
Dengeki Daisy by Kyosuke Motomi

The above category may sound kinda creepy, but Dengeki Daisy is honestly one of the cutest new manga I’ve read all year. After Teru’s brother, her only remain relative, dies, she relies on the mysterious “DAISY” for emotional support. DAISY, however, is just an anonymous person who texts her words of encouragement. The life of the impoverished and bullied Teru doesn’t get much better after she has to repay a debt to the grouchy school janitor. Fortunately for Teru, the janitor is looking out for her in more ways than she knows. Thus, this gift would be perfect for anyone who loves their men hot-and-cold!

For the person who’s struggling with their identity:
Wandering Son by Shimura Takako

On a serious note, 2011 has been an awful year to be gay, lesbian, bisexual or transgendered, even as society slowly begins to recognize their equal rights. Wouldn’t it be wonderful to show a person struggling with their identity, sexual or otherwise, that you sympathize? Perhaps Wandering Son isn’t the best gift in to show them that their struggles will be easily accepted, but it could certainly show your recipient that they are not alone and there are others who care about them out there. Plus, showing them that there’s a whole world of people out there who are similar to them is sure to lift your giftee’s spirits.

For the foodie:
Not Love But Delicious Foods Make Me So Happy! by Fumi Yoshinaga

If you are a foodie, you know what it means to really geek out over insanely delicious food and Not Love but Delicious Foods is Fumi Yoshinaga’s ultimate foodie geek-out. Each story features a thinly-veiled Yoshinaga eating delicious food all over Tokyo and describing her conquests in mouth-watering detail. Never thought you would drool over unagidon? Yoshinaga will take you there. Perfect for anyone who loves food, or perhaps someone who is taking a food-centric trip to Tokyo soon.

For the person who still stumps you:
Gift cards
As cold and impersonal as gift cards seem, there are plenty of manga fans who welcome them. It means they get to choose their own gift, at their leisure, without paying for that huge stack of manga. You can’t go wrong with that.

That’s it for this year’s Great Shoujo Manga Gift Guide! Happy manga shopping, and if you need more suggestions as to what to buy your otaku friends, you can find the 2011 Great Manga Gift Guide list here.

Posted in manga, opinion, reviews | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 10 Comments

2011 Great Manga Gift Guide- Week 1 Round Up!

It’s been an exciting week for the 2011 Great Manga Gift Guide with lots of excellent entries from esteemed anime and manga bloggers out there.

First up there’s Erica Friedman with a Retro Gift Guide full of older shoujo anime and manga that have come back into print in the past year. Of course, in traditional Okazu style, all the suggestions are yuri-friendly.

Anna has a number of great suggestions up on Manga Report this year, including my personal favorite: A Bride’s Story!

Rob of Panel Patter brings us a wide spread of different genres in his gift guide this year, all of critically acclaimed manga well worth the time of any reader.

While Tom Spurgeon’s holiday gift guide at The Comics Reporter is mostly comic book-related, he does take the time to include a number of great manga suggestions that take into consideration the tastes of people who are primarily graphic novel fans.

Josh Tolentino has gift ideas for anime and manga lovers from all the contributors at Japanator, just in case your friends care more about Puella Magi Madoka Magica than Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon.

Tony Yao’s gift guide reads like a love affair with the best shounen and seinen manga of the year, but still makes sure to include some ideas for shoujo and josei fans.

Kate Dacey bucks convention at her blog, The Manga Critic, and goes for manga and anime-related gifts that you can’t find in a plain old chain bookstore!

Deb Aoki gives us a one two punch with her gift guide for manga readers and her gift guide for supporting comics and good causes at the same time.

Finally, although plenty of bloggers love doing the Great Manga Gift Guides, this year there are some bloggers fighting back against what they see as cold, impersonal gift giving…

On Rocket Bomber, Matt Blind suggests giving cash instead of manga because you probably won’t get the person what they actually like. And hey, who doesn’t like cash?

Milo Turnbull of Blog of the North Star just finds gift guides to be a superficial way to find a gift for someone.

Both bloggers make excellent points, but to take a page from my life, I was overjoyed as a teen whenever someone got me a manga-related gift. If any of those people used a manga gift guide, I didn’t care and I couldn’t say that I’d blame them for getting assistance; most of them didn’t know much about manga at all.

Oh well, we can agree to disagree. Still, it poses a few interesting questions, such as: are gift guides really useful? And: does the gift feel like it’s more shallow if you use a gift guide for suggestions? Feel free to comment!

As for the 2011 Great Manga Gift Guide, it doesn’t seem to be stopping any time soon! If you want to find out more about the 2011 Great Manga Gift Guides, please check out this post.

If you would like to have your holiday manga gift guide added to the 2011 Great Manga Gift Guides, please feel free to leave a comment on this or any other Great Manga Gift Guide-related post, or use the twitter hashtag #gmgg. (And don’t forget to include a link to your gift guide!)

Happy holiday manga shopping! See you next week!

Posted in manga | Tagged , , , , , , | 4 Comments

Giving Thanks and Great Presents: (A Call for the 2011 Great Manga Gift Guide)

Hi readers!

As you probably know, today is Thanksgiving in the U.S. Canada has already had their Thanksgiving and I honestly can’t remember if any other country celebrates a similar national holiday.

Here’s what I’m thankful for:

  • A supportive family and boyfriend who allow me to lean on them in order to fulfill my dream of being a manga editor.
  • The clients who keep sending me awesome manga to work on. It’s so much fun. 🙂
  • Certain manga that have hit the bestsellers list this year and last.
  • A large stack of manga to read, including the huge stack of stuff that I can’t read quite yet, but that I’ll get to read in the near future after making certain purchases.
  • A fantastic manga-loving community, not only on my own blog, but on Twitter and on their own blogs.
  • Anything sweet with pumpkin in it, especially pumpkin pie. *drool*

That being said, tomorrow America begins its descent into a crazed retail frenzy as we all prepare for Christmas. (Let’s not pretend here, there might as well not be any other religious winter holidays to the stores & to certain people.) Ah, Black Friday…

But since Black Friday is the traditional start of most people’s holiday shopping, it’s a good time to get the 2011 Great Manga Gift Guide going!

You may remember that I hosted the Great Manga Gift Guide last year, and that the year before that it was started by David P. Welsh of Manga Curmudgeon/Manga Bookshelf and Erica Friedman of Ozaku in response a manga-less holiday novel gift guide published by the New York Times.

This year, Brigid Alverson has beaten all of us manga bloggers to the punch by posting her holiday gift guide over at MTV Geek.

But don’t let that deter you! The 2011 Great Manga Gift Guide will be running until December 21, 2011 and I’ll be collecting and adding each entry sent my way to the 2011 Great Manga Gift Guide Archives.

If you’d like to add your gift guide to the 2011 Great Manga Gift Guide, feel free to leave a comment on any Great Manga Gift Guide-related post on All About Manga or use the twitter hashtag #gmgg. Don’t forget to include a link to your gift guide!

Happy manga shopping and Happy Thanksgiving!

P.S. If you  need a blog to host your Great Manga Gift Guide, drop me a line! I’d be more than happy to host any gift guides that need a home!

Posted in comics, manga, opinion, reviews | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

The 2011 Great Manga Gift Guides

Welcome to the 2011 Great Manga Gift Guide! This is the archive for all the Great Manga Gift Guides posted between 11-21-11 and 12-21-11. They are here for your perusal, whether you would like to shop for your manga-loving friends or whether you just want to know what manga bloggers think the best of manga of 2011 are.

To find out more about the 2011 Great Manga Gift Guides, please check out this post.

If you would like to have your holiday manga gift guide added to the 2011 Great Manga Gift Guides, please feel free to leave a comment on this or any other Great Manga Gift Guide-related post, or use the twitter hashtag #gmgg. (And don’t forget to include a link to your gift guide!)

Happy holiday manga shopping!

Anna for Manga Report

Brigid Alverson for MTV Geek

Daniella Orihuela-Gruber for All About Manga

A manga gift guide and a gift guide for comic book & manga lovers who’d love to give to a good cause, both from Deb Aoki of Manga.About.com.

Erica Friedman for Ozaku

Josh Tolentino for Japanator

Kate Dacey for The Manga Critic

Kris for Comic Attack

Linda for Animemiz.com

Matt Blind for Rocket Bomber

Milo Turnbull for Blog of the North Star

Rob for Panel Patter

Seichan for CLAMP*NEWS

Tom Spurgeon for The Comics Reporter

Tony Yao for Manga Therapy

Posted in comics, Discussion, manga, opinion, reviews | Tagged , , | 15 Comments

Discussion: What’s Your Favorite Scifi and/or Fantasy Manga?

OK, so I’m doing a panel on underrated scifi and fantasy manga next week at Loscon 38. I’ve already figured out that I want to talk about Planetes, To Terra, Pluto, From Far Away and Twin Spica, but I also don’t want to miss anything!

So, even if I don’t wind up using it in my presentation, I would love to hear about your favorite, underrated scifi or fantasy manga, why you love it so much and why you think it deserves much more attention!

My personal favorite is From Far Away by Kyoko Hikawa. (I know I’ve mentioned it on this blog before, but it will NEVER get enough love to me.) It’s a sweeping fantasy that has the two main characters, Noriko and Izark, become the Awakening and the Sky Demon. Everyone pretty much views these two forces as destructive, and the two must keep their identities secret as Izark struggles to control his dangerous powers.

Sometimes the characters seem a bit Mary Sue-ish as they defeat their enemies with love and other positive feelings, but they also struggle greatly with their imperfections. I also find that the mangaka deals with issues with a certain realism. For example, Noriko struggles with learning the local language after arriving in the new world, which isn’t something you see in too many fantasy manga. (And it actually takes her time to learn!)

Another strong point of the series is how strong and/or respected women are. It would be all too easy to have all the women be dainty little flowers or to throw in a lot of sexual violence to intimidate even the strongest lady, but Hikawa steers clear of this. That being said, Hikawa showcases a lot of personalities across both sexes. There are strong women, dainty women, scary-looking men who are really softies, skinny men, men and women with noble demeanors; it’s refreshing to see all kinds of people and all kinds of body types in a manga.

A lot of people I know have never heard of From Far Away, probably because it was released during the Great American Manga Boom. By now, it’s probably quite out-of-print, but not ridiculously expensive on eBay or Amazon. (Thank goodness.)

Anyway, please let me know which scifi and fantasy manga you love in the comments below! Thanks!

P.S. Has anyone noticed how remarkably similar To Terra is to Battlestar Galactica? (Although I think To Terra predates the original BSG a little bit.)

P.P.S. In case you’re wondering, I’m going to stick to legally-published-in-English manga for my presentation. Might as well.

Posted in Discussion, manga | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | 5 Comments

All About Manga Panels at Loscon 38, Thanksgiving Weekend

Hi everyone!

Just wanted to let you know that I’ll be on two panels at Loscon 38 on Thanksgiving weekend. (Black Friday, to be specific.)

Here’s what I’ll be speaking about:

Friday from 1:30 pm – 2:30 pm in the New Orleans room
Best Fantasy Manga You’ve Never Heard Of—Come and find out what you’re missing.
Daniella Orihuela-Gruber

Friday from 3:00 pm – 4:00 pm in the New Orleans room
Book Piracy and Other Art Crimes—Has the internet really destroyed civilization, or is there still hope? Daniella Orihuela-Gruber and Curt Steindler

The con is at the LAX Marriott, so if you’re on your way home or just dropping your relatives off at the airport, you should come! Or, you know, if you’re more interested in scifi than waiting in crazy long lines for a good deal on a TV.

If you can’t come to Loscon, then you should give me some suggestions for your favorite, overlooked fantasy & scifi manga!

Hope to see you there!

Posted in comics, manga, news | Tagged , , , , , , | 1 Comment

A Day (and 15 minutes) at PMX

Despite the fact that I live in Los Angeles, which is a very large area, we get some very small cons throughout the year. Pacific Media Expo (PMX) is one of those cons and the size is a very good indication of it’s quality, unfortunately.

This year the con was held at the LAX Hilton, which would be as good of a location as any, except for a few things. First, and foremost, is the parking. The hotel and the surrounding areas cater to LAX-bound travelers most of the year and so parking is obscenely high. The Hilton did nothing to discount their parking for PMX attendees, driving many to a Parking Spot lot next door when the Hilton lot filled up. Thank goodness both were $20 a day. In comparison, the LAX Marriott a few doors down, discounts parking for Anime Los Angeles (and I’m assuming other cons like Gallifrey and the Costume College, which are also held there.)

Once you entered the hotel, you were met with large lobby packed with cosplayers creating multiple fire hazards and a lone sign for a swap meet right by the doors. If you went through a certain set of doors to the right and you have good eyesight, you could see an info desk way on the other side of the hotel. However, if you entered the hotel from the left, you would have just seen cosplayers and the hotel check-in counter. Nothing to indicate where registration was or where anything else was. For some reason, registration was tucked into a tiny room in an area only used by con ops and security. I realize the hotel was not built to host anime cons, but the layout was just too scattered for my taste and I couldn’t easily find things on more than one occasion .

Cell phone coverage throughout the hotel grounds was pretty lacking, but considering how bad cell phone coverage is in the LAX Marriott, it could have been worse.

I looked at the programming for the con and found almost nothing that interested me except for a Sailor Moon panel and a We Heart Japan panel. I wound up missing the Sailor Moon panel due to difficulty finding parking and was told I wasn’t missing much. The We Heart Japan panel about the organization’s efforts to help victims of the Tohoku earthquake and tsunami was fun, informative. One of the panelists had actually been at the Fukushima Dai-ichi nuclear plant at the time of the earthquake and had to evacuate soon afterward. His anecdotes were a highlight and I hope We Heart Japan brings him to every panel they can in the future. I could have attended the Suzumi Atsushi (of Venus Versus Virus fame) panel, but I had never read her manga and it wasn’t for sale in the dealer’s room.

Unfortunately, attending the We Heart Japan panel showed just how disorganized PMX’s scheduling was. The schedule given out by PMX themselves indicated that it was at 3:30 pm, but the panel room schedule said the panel was at 3:00 pm. The volunteer guarding the room thought that the current occupants were the We Heart Japan people, but the panelists themselves thought their panel was at 4 pm. Oy gevalt.

Admittedly, there seemed to be a lot of content for fans of Lolita fashion (a boutique, panels with designers, swap meets, scavenger hunts and plenty of exhibitors) and Visual Kei. Had I not quit Lolita fashion and Visual Kei fandom a few years ago, I might have been more excited about PMX’s programming.

The dealer’s room contained the one saving grace I found at the con: a manga peddler who had fantastic deals on out of print titles from now-defunct publishers. I bought 36 volumes of manga for only $60, which was amazing. I came back the next day ONLY because I wanted to see if I had overlooked anything on their shelves. The dealer’s room also had a Kapibara-san booth, which excited me because I’m fond on the large furry rodents and unusual Japanese character merchandise. I’d never seen that particular character have a booth at a con before, which makes me wonder why they chose to exhibit at PMX. (Wish I could have justified a giant Kapibara-san plush, but my apartment is too tiny.)

I didn’t peruse the artist’s alley much except to commission a friend of mine, who said that she was having difficulties making back her con expenses because the artist’s alley was so hard to find.

The last thing I did at the con (aside from coming back quickly to shop for manga) was attend a swap meet. However, due to poor judging on the part of the con, it was more like a lesson in claustrophobia there were so many people crammed into this tiny space. I lasted five minutes at the swap meet after making sure there weren’t any manga I really wanted. Truly, this event needs to be in a MUCH bigger room, even if there aren’t that many tables, as evidenced by some poor soul in an electric wheelchair who couldn’t even slowly inch through the crowd. I don’t know if this chaos lasted throughout the evening, but the size of the room was such that it was clear a bigger space was definitely needed no matter what.

As far as I can tell,  PMX is a decent con for cosplayers and Visual Kei fans, and a pretty good con for Lolita fashion. For just about everyone else, it’s a decent con for seeing your friends and maybe spending lots of time in a video room or the game room. The PMX organizers have excellent taste in local food trucks, thankfully. This year they had Truck Norris, which was quite tasty, and last year they had Nom Nom Truck, which is a very popular LA truck.

As for next year, I think I’ll skip PMX.

Posted in manga, opinion, reviews | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment